• Home
  • Resources
    • Find Resources by Topic Tags
    • Cybersecurity Policy Chart
    • CSIAC Reports
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Cybersecurity Digest
    • Standards & Reference Docs
    • Journals
    • Certifications
    • Acronym DB
    • Cybersecurity Related Websites
  • Services
    • Free Technical Inquiry
    • Core Analysis Task (CAT) Program
    • Subject Matter Expert (SME) Network
    • Training
    • Contact Us
  • Community
    • Upcoming Events
    • Cybersecurity
    • Modeling & Simulation
    • Knowledge Management
    • Software Engineering
  • About
    • About the CSIAC
    • The CSIAC Team
    • Subject Matter Expert (SME) Support
    • DTIC’s IAC Program
    • DTIC’s R&E Gateway
    • DTIC STI Program
    • FAQs
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Login / Register

CSIAC

Cyber Security and Information Systems Information Analysis Center

  • Resources
    • Find Resources by Topic Tags
    • Cybersecurity Policy Chart
    • CSIAC Reports
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Cybersecurity Digest
    • Standards & Reference Docs
    • Journals
    • Certifications
    • Acronym DB
    • Cybersecurity Websites
  • Services
    • Free Technical Inquiry
    • Core Analysis Task (CAT) Program
    • Subject Matter Expert (SME) Network
    • Training
    • Contact
  • Community
    • Upcoming Events
    • Cybersecurity
    • Modeling & Simulation
    • Knowledge Management
    • Software Engineering
  • About
    • About the CSIAC
    • The CSIAC Team
    • Subject Matter Expert (SME) Support
    • DTIC’s IAC Program
    • DTIC’s R&E Gateway
    • DTIC STI Program
    • FAQs
  • Cybersecurity
  • Modeling & Simulation
  • Knowledge Management
  • Software Engineering
/ Journal Issues / Modeling & Simulation Special Edition / A Marine Take on Live, Virtual, and Constructive Initiatives

A Marine Take on Live, Virtual, and Constructive Initiatives

Published in Journal of Cyber Security and Information Systems
Volume: 3 Number: 3 - Modeling & Simulation Special Edition

Author: Mr. Brett Telford
Posted: 02/09/2016 | Leave a Comment

“Being ready is not what matters. What matters is winning after you get there.”
Marine General Victor Krulak

Introduction: Preparing to Win

Modeling and Simulation (M&S) will not win any battles for the Marine Corps. As has been the case for nearly two-and-a-half centuries, real Marines with real weapons and real ammunition will win our battles. But being ready is still a necessary condition for prevailing in combat. And because M&S is a monumentally important part of being ready, Marine Corps M&S needs to do everything it can to ensure that Marines are ready. With current fiscal constraints, M&S is particularly important, given its tendency to be far more affordable than alternatives.

In the Marine Corps, as in other services, the Title X tasks to “man, train, and equip” aren’t getting any easier. Indeed, the diversity of threats to our country is expanding and traverses nearly the entire spectrum of war. As the smallest service, the Marine Corps must employ the most efficient means available to ensure our forces have the tools, training, and support they need to meet these diverse threats. And when you’re talking about transforming the cumbersome and the expensive into the convenient and the affordable, you probably need to be talking about M&S.

Recognizing the value of M&S and the need to work closely with our joint counterparts, the Marine Corps recently reorganized its M&S management structure to match the M&S management structure in the Navy. Our managerial framework, like the Navy’s, now has four communities – acquisition, analysis, experimentation, and training. The Marine Corps M&S Management Office (MCMSMO) coordinates M&S activities across these four communities and reports to the Commanding General, Marine Corps Combat Development Command (CG, MCCDC). This structure lets our service share information across M&S communities within the Marine Corps, and it lets us provide a single, coherent voice to our counterparts across the DoD M&S enterprise. Internal and external coordination is important to DoD in general, and to the Marine Corps in particular – we must leverage existing capabilities across services and across communities whenever doing so accelerates the achievement of an important goal.

Now, in 2015, when you think about Live-Virtual-Constructive (LVC) events in the Marine Corps, you are almost always thinking about training. However, LVC capabilities transcend a single community, as demonstrated by the DoD and our sister services, who are already actively planning to use LVC across multiple M&S domains. To avoid falling behind our sister services, the Marine Corps needs to plan for LVC to grow. This paper will outline how the Marine Corps can set the stage for a strong LVC future, and it will do so by providing context on the state of M&S in our M&S communities (not just the training community, which is the vanguard for how the Marine Corps will use LVC to support training).

The Urgency of Live/Virtual Constructive Initatives

Perhaps no other category of M&S efforts holds as much promise as LVC initiatives. Currently, the training community is the big dog and very nearly the only dog, in Marine Corps LVC. Thus, talking about an LVC Training Environment (LVC-TE) in 2015 and talking about LVC in 2015 are two nearly identical conversations. Still, LVC-TE solutions devised in 2015 or 2016 shouldn’t bind Marine LVC-TE to 2015 or 2016. Likewise, LVC-TE solutions of today shouldn’t constrain broad, multi-community LVC in the future. Technological progress may hold situations in which LVC will matter to people outside the training world (i.e. analysts, acquisition specialists, or concept developers). The Marine Corps needs to allow for progress, which invariably brings with it the unforeseen.

Before this discussion of LVC goes any further, a brief discussion of terms and definitions is in order. For those of you less familiar with LVC, it’s helpful to think of the words this way:

  • LIVE: Real people operating real systems
  • VIRTUAL: Real people operating simulated systems
  • CONSTRUCTIVE: Simulated people operating simulated systems

For those of you intimately familiar with LVC, we ask that you check any tendentious inclinations toward hair splitting. Yes, you can play semantic games for hours, tediously pontificating on the gray areas between live and virtual; virtual and constructive; and constructive and live. This paper is a discussion of issues and ideas. We can all dive into the rabbit holes later. (And most of us have lost many hours we’ll never get back listening to explorations of the ambiguities in these three terms.)

Now that we have a handle on these terms that are attracting so much attention, we need to remind ourselves that when DoD gets excited about an idea, the Good Idea Fairy isn’t far behind. Currently, LVC is the darling of the buzzword chanters and the PowerPoint prophets. Any number of DoD briefings promises full integration of countless M&S capabilities via LVC technology. There’s a tantalizing air of legitimacy to pitches for on-demand distributed training, reuse of models, and operating from the cloud. It’s easy to conjure visions of Marines immersed in a digital world that will meet their every need. Commanders are left with the impression that all they have to do is press a button, and they will have instantaneous, multi-echelon training (as well as analysis and experimentation). It will be just like Xbox Live®!

Of course, the reality is much different. Budgets aren’t unlimited; DoD isn’t the entertainment industry; and the speed of our bureaucracy can handicap us as we try to keep pace with the speed of technological progress.

The Marine Corps recognizes these challenges at the same time it recognizes the importance of LVC. The Marine Corps must review its LVC plan, as Gen. Joseph Dunford wrote in his recently published “Commandant’s Planning Guidance.” “We will particularly focus on better leveraging modern immersive training and simulation technologies.” Significantly, Gen. Dunford also directs that any efforts the Marine Corps takes should be based on understood priorities and requirements. In other words, the Marine Corps will pursue LVC capabilities where they make sense, but uttering the acronym “LVC” doesn’t give you carte blanche to hook up assorted M&S systems just for the sake of hooking them up. Integration between independent capabilities should only occur where it needs to occur.

The spectrum of uses for LVC environments is rapidly increasing across multiple M&S communities. However, the cost in time, personnel, and resources for setting up LVC can increase too, if you’re not careful (and even if you are). Many existing environments don’t effectively reuse common capabilities. Instead, there are LVC environments that are highly customized for specific operational requirements, and these environments must be built/dismantled for individual events. Needless to say, these one-off LVC events are costly, inefficient, and unconducive to technological progress. In order to correct this trend, CG, MCCDC will help guide the development of a Marine Corps-wide LVC capability.

Distributed Simulation Engineering and Execution Process

Several systems engineering processes exist, but the Distributed Simulation Engineering and Execution Process (DSEEP) articulates the specific steps that are most appropriate for distributed M&S capabilities. The Simulation Interoperability and Standards Organization (SISO) and the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) have produced an overlay that accommodates environments requiring multiple architectures; in other words, SISO and IEEE have created an approach that handles LVC environments such as the ones DoD employs.

LVC requires a strategic vision that rests upon a strong foundation of where technology is and how this status quo came to be. For USMC LVC, MCCDC will look to formalize the LVC enterprise; that means devising a vision, strategy, and management approach. This vision will reflect the concepts of the Marine Air-Ground Task Force (MAGTF), and will reach across our four M&S communities to see how they can leverage LVC capabilities. This approach necessitates a detailed understanding of the LVC requirements for each element of the MAGTF. To help understand these issues, MCCDC will produce a white paper identifying the Marine Corps requirements that M&S working via LVC can support. The requirements will be arranged in blocks and placed in a hierarchy. In turn, Marine Corps planners will be better able to harness LVC. It’s worth noting that executing LVC in the present and the near future is only half the battle and is currently limited to the training domain. The ultimate key is a Marine Corps service-level LVC policy that enables capabilities to grow and be used in unforeseen ways, i.e., a policy that doesn’t constrain future LVC with the perspectives of the bureaucrat or technician stuck in 2015.

Pages: Page 1 Page 2 Page 3

Previous Article:
« Director’s Introduction
Next Article:
Rediscover the Defense Modeling & Simulation Catalog »

NOTE: Any reference, direct or implied, to a commercially available product, service, or software application is for illustration only, and is not a Marine Corps endorsement of that product or software.

Author

Mr. Brett Telford
Mr. Brett Telford
Mr. Brett Telford is the Director of the Marine Corps M&S Management Office. He began working for the Marine Corps in 2007 following a 20 year career in the United States Air Force (USAF). In this capacity, Mr. Telford acts as the Marine Corps point of contact for the development of Joint and Service level M&S policy. In addition, he leads the Marine Corps M&S Integrated Product Team (IPT) that seeks to leverage activities across the fleet and improve the use of M&S throughout the Marine Corps. Mr. Telford entered military service in 1987 upon graduation from the USAF Academy. During his career he served in a variety of operational and program management positions ranging in scope from supporting wing level operations to the development of Air Staff budget submissions. As a certified Acquisition Professional Development Program (ADAP) Level III program manager he has led the development and fielding of classified aircrew trainers, constructive simulations, and engineering level models.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment Cancel

You must be logged in to post a comment.

sidebar

Blog Sidebar

Featured Content

The DoD Cybersecurity Policy Chart

The DoD Cybersecurity Policy Chart

This chart captures the tremendous breadth of applicable policies, some of which many cybersecurity professionals may not even be aware, in a helpful organizational scheme.

View the Policy Chart

Featured Subject Matter Expert (SME): Cully Patch

An internal CSIAC SME with a passion for learning, teaching, and supporting the warfighter, Mr. Cully Patch has been a member of the CSIAC staff for 5 years. Cully was instrumental in leading the development and instruction of an extensive course on DoD Cybersecurity Analysis and Reporting (DoDCAR) - a threat-based approach to addressing system cybersecurity. As a senior program manager for cybersecurity and intelligence, Mr. Patch has extensive experience in providing cybersecurity training and education to both university students and military operators. Cully is a retired US Air Force military officer with career accomplishments in the fields of research, Intelligence, cybersecurity operations, planning, and technical course instruction. CSIAC is honored to have Mr. Patch as a subject matter expert, where he leads teams of technologists through problem solving, training program development, scientific and technical information generation, and analysis of complex system requirements.

View SME's Contributed Content

CSIAC Report - Smart Cities, Smart Bases and Secure Cloud Architecture for Resiliency by Design

Integration of Smart City Technologies to create Smart Bases for DoD will require due diligence with respect to the security of the data produced by Internet of Things (IOT) and Industrial Internet of Things (IIOT). This will increase more so with the rollout of 5G and increased automation "at the edge". Commercially, data will be moving to the cloud first, and then stored for process improvement analysis by end-users. As such, implementation of Secure Cloud Architectures is a must. This report provides some use cases and a description of a risk based approach to cloud data security. Clear understanding, adaptation, and implementation of a secure cloud framework will provide the military the means to make progress in becoming a smart military.

Read the Report

CSIAC Journal - Data-Centric Environment: Rise of Internet-Based Modern Warfare “iWar”

CSIAC Journal Cover Volume 7 Number 4

This journal addresses a collection of modern security concerns that range from social media attacks and internet-connected devices to a hypothetical defense strategy for private sector entities.

Read the Journal

CSIAC Journal M&S Special Edition - M&S Applied Across Broad Spectrum Defense and Federal Endeavors

CSIAC Journal Cover Volume 7 Number 3

This Special Edition of the CSIAC Journal highlights a broad array of modeling and simulation contributions – whether in training, testing, experimentation, research, engineering, or other endeavors.

Read the Journal

CSIAC Journal - Resilient Industrial Control Systems (ICS) & Cyber Physical Systems (CPS)

CSIAC Journal Cover Volume 7 Number 2

This edition of the CSIAC Journal focuses on the topic of cybersecurity of Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS), particularly those that make up Critical Infrastructure (CI).

Read the Journal

Recent Video Podcasts

  • Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification (CMMC): The Road to Compliance Series: The CSIAC Podcast
  • Deep Learning for Radio Frequency Target Classification Series: CSIAC Webinars
  • A Brief Side-by-Side Comparison Between C++ and Rust – Part 3 Series: Programming Language Comparisons
  • A Brief Side-by-Side Comparison Between C++ and Rust – Part 2 Series: Programming Language Comparisons
  • A Brief Side-by-Side Comparison Between C++ and Rust – Part 1 Series: Programming Language Comparisons
View all Podcasts

Upcoming Events

Mon 12

18th USENIX Symposium on Networked Systems Design and Implementation (NSDI)

April 12 - April 14
Boston MA
Organizer: USENIX
Tue 13

Identity Management Day

April 13
Organizer: Identity Defined Security Alliance (IDSA)
Thu 29

Data Connectors Phoenix Virtual Cybersecurity Summit

April 29
Organizer: Data Connectors
636-778-9495
May 17

SANS Purple Team Summit & Training 2021

May 17 - May 28
Organizer: SANS Institute
May 27

DockerCon LIVE 2021

May 27 @ 06:00 - 14:00 EDT
View all Events

Footer

CSIAC Products & Services

  • Free Technical Inquiry
  • Core Analysis Tasks (CATs)
  • Resources
  • Events Calendar
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Product Feedback Form

About CSIAC

The CSIAC is a DoD-sponsored Center of Excellence in the fields of Cybersecurity, Software Engineering, Modeling & Simulation, and Knowledge Management & Information Sharing.Learn More

Contact Us

Phone:800-214-7921
Email:info@csiac.org
Address:   266 Genesee St.
Utica, NY 13502
Send us a Message
US Department of Defense Logo USD(R&E) Logo DTIC Logo DoD IACs Logo

Copyright 2012-2021, Quanterion Solutions Incorporated

Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Accessibility Information
Accessibility / Section 508 | FOIA | Link Disclaimer | No Fear Act | Policy Memoranda | Privacy, Security & Copyright | Recovery Act | USA.Gov

This website uses cookies to provide our services and to improve your experience. By using this site, you consent to the use of our cookies. To read more about the use of our site, please click "Read More". Otherwise, click "Dismiss" to hide this notice. Dismiss Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.

SAVE & ACCEPT